Team RorschachvsTeam Thor (MCU)

Created by Martin

Comments

DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Yea, Ok
soratoumiga
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Blue naked guy's powers wouldn't work on Thor and Hulk.
show 13 replies
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Why would he not be able to erase them from existence? They don't have any sort of immunity to that
soratoumiga
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) He doesn't erase from existence, he isn't a reality warper, he's a matter manipulator. And a mediocre one, at that. His powers only worked on regular humans, not superhumans and above.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Give me proof to how he can't do it to superhumans and above
soratoumiga
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Umm... the whole Watchmen movie. He only desitegrated people with human durability. Not superhuman, magicians, gods etc.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Because there were none of those people to erase, durability isn't a factor in this. By that logic that shuts down Nemian's idea of Hulk and/or Thor speedblitzing, which they've never been shown to do.
soratoumiga
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Feats > statements. They have many more feats, and Doctor has little of them. It all comes back to the fact that he most likely can't desintegrate superhumans. Why? Because he never did it, people think he is a god, but he never met real gods.
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Except yeah, let's disregard Infinity War where Thor was moving with his lightning and speedblitzed Thanos.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) But still, he has never done it to superhumans, correct, but that's still not a logical answer. There's no magic behind why he can't do it to superhumans, there is no mega durability behind why he can't do to superhumans, there is nothing behind why he couldn't do it
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Until he shows the capability, he can't do it, end of story.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) And then we go back to TOAA situation, TOAA has created an omniverse, which is an above human level feat, making him able to defeat a human, Doctor Manhattan has killed someone with a hand motion, which is an above Thor level feat, making him able to defeat Thor
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) You're actually acting really stupid, you're not stupid, so stop acting like it, if you think killing someone with a wave of a hand is impressive, I don't know what to tell you, Manhattan killing someone with a wave doesn't correlate to TOAA being above peak human, that feat is continent level, Thor withstood the energy of a dwarf star, so he's at least ten million times more powerful than Manhattan.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Okay, let me break this down. It's not the difference between Manhattan's power levels and TOAA's power levels, it's the logic behind it. TOAA is above human because he has a feat higher than humans, same as these 2, you then went on to say how Thor has withstood the energy of a dwarf star, making him more powerful than Manhattan, but Thor still has to interact with his opponent to do that, Manhattan does not. Thor speed blitzing would be the secret to him winning, but he can't, because he hasn't done it before. Now you're probably thinking "Well Manhattan hasn't wiped anything above superhuman before", but he has still done it. Thor has not shown the ability to speed blitz, he has not done it before. Manhattan, on the other hand, has wiped something before.
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) I literally just proved to you that Thor could move MACH 70, at the very least, yet you still for some ridiculous reason don't think he could speedblitz Doctor Manhattan, that's cynical, you're cynical, TOAA literally has no relevance to Doctor Manhattan, because TOAA has proved to have feats above peak human, while Manhattan has not in the movie, therefore he can't until he proves he can, end of story, you don't win this debate, I promise you there isn't any way you can, Thor speedblitzed that Ice Monster on Johutunheim, ripping a hole through him, not, Thor has become hundreds of times more impressive since then, so that, again, ALSO, disproves your ridiculous statements, all Manhattan has ever wiped was a measly pathetic human past his prime, you have no evidence to suggest Manhattan can go above that.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Doctor Manhattan solos?
show 16 replies
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Thor solos*
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Have you seen Watchmen?
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Yes, and Dr Manhattan has never beat anyone above low superhuman, thus his powers are a fallacy, he'd get speedblitzed by Thor or Hulk
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) How can he not erase them out of existence [spoiler]Like he did to Rorschach?[/spoiler]? Thor has never been shown to get at those speed-blitzing speeds, neither has Hulk
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Because dude, Thor isn't a normal human, he is fueled by godly power, he's worth quadrillions of humans, bare minimum.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) That's not a reason why he can't erase him. Doctor Manhattan just has to move his hand to win this fight
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) That's not how it works, you have to prove to me that he could do it against Thor, I don't have to prove he can't, you have to prove that he has the ability to do so, or it's irrelevant.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) It's just common sense, we've never seen TOAA defeat a human being, does that mean he can't do it? No, it doesn't
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) What you're saying is complete and utter horse droppings, TOAA can erase a human because he created an entire omniverse, which is above human level feats, therefore he is more powerful than them, that's logic because of feats, while Dr Manhattan has NEVER had a decent feat to kill anyone above human levels, so your argument is completely invalid and utter crap, unless there is any indication of him being above that, HE ISN'T HIGHER THAN PEAK HUMAN LEVELS.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Doctor Manhattan has killed someone with a hand motion, which is above Thor levels feats. Therefore he should be able to beat him correct? Oh and btw, he didn't speed blitz Thanos, he used lightning to come to Thanos really fast, not a speed blitz ;) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX65s2N8fkQ
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Thor scaled a structure 1,000's of feet tall in that battle, in a few seconds, and then he flew to another in less than that time, they were thousands of feet in distance too, so yeah, Thor would speed blitz Dr Manhattan, dude, you are obviously too tired, because your debating skills right now are terrible.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) I think you're tired because yet again you are showing some big hypocrisy. Using your logic, Thor can't speed blitz because he has never speed blitz someone before
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Thor flew 1'000s of feet in a few seconds, he moved a few thousand feet about a kilometre in 3 seconds that's 1,200 km per hour, that's way faster than Dr Manhattan can react.
=
Also, I know he moved WAY faster while escaping the fire Dragon, where he was moving dozens of km per second, let's say 2 dozen kms, that's 86,400 kmph, he'd blitz Manhattan like nothing.
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) When he escaped the Dragon, he was moving AT LEAST MACH 70.
DarkProdigy
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Again, using the logic that you have used against me, he has never. Done it. Before. I gtg now, we'll continue this tomorrow
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Yes, he has, the first Thor movie, Ragnorok and Infinity War, it sounds like your mouth ain't connected to your brain.
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Thor solos
windshadow
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Movie versions right since it's MCU Avengers?
show 4 replies
Martin
Martin 302 d
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
not voted Yes movie version
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) Every girl I ever went out with has gone lez... :(
IMABATMAN42
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
1 year member
Team Thor (MCU) That's random...
TheNemianLion
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
Team Thor (MCU) But true.
Martin
Martin 302 d
Team Rorschach vs Team Thor (MCU)
2 year member
not voted Watchmen vs Avengers

Voting feed

Doctor_Thorantmann
Team Rorschach wins!
AkhilPDX
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
Creature99
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
ManofPower
Team Rorschach wins!
DarkProdigy
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
IMABATMAN42
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
soratoumiga
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
windshadow
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
LordTracer
Team Thor (MCU) wins!
TheNemianLion
Team Thor (MCU) wins!