Searching...

The One-Above-AllvsThe Writer

Created by LordDarkless

21 wins (51.2%)
0 (0%)
20 wins (48.8%)
The One-Above-AllThe One-Above-AllEarth-616
power stats
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Official Superhero Database stats. | Class: 0
The WriterGrant MorrisonPrime Earth
power stats
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Official Superhero Database stats. | Class: 0

Comments

MoNsTeR
MoNsTeR 12 h 23 m
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
14 months member
The One-Above-All Toaa contains every marvel editor/writer including jack kirby and stan lee vs grant morrison
show 1 reply
MoNsTeR
MoNsTeR 12 h 21 m
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
14 months member
The One-Above-All if i'm wrong debunk me
Chijb
Chijb 1 mo 28 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
4 months member
The Writer Mr_Incognito: The Writer takes the form of GM but is the combination of all DC writers who wrote the first story on the overvoid, above fiction. TOAA is a fictional character made to represent the writer of the story. JUST SPREADING THE MESSAGE!
Actual writers > Fictional writer created to write the stories
Writer is tier 0, TOAA is high 1-A. Writer wins.
Last edited: 1 mo 28 d ago.
show 10 replies
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 28 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All He's not the actual writer.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer Wrong again.
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All Until you show evidence for this claim that's come far too long, it really isn't.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer I have, you just won’t accept it. I have it from the mouth of GM himself and gave you quite a few scans and sites.
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All The websites claim basically the same thing as you with no evidence to support it. The scan you use and the scan they use in no way indicates anything about the Writer being all writers in one.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer In order for a character's stats to be changed, they shouldn't have to always be run by you or conform to your standards of evidence. You shouldn't have a stats monopoly on all of the characters.This character does not represent only Grant Morrison, but every writer in DC history, as "The Writer" was the entity responsible for the creation of DC Comics within Monitor-Mind The Overvoid, as shown in Final Crisis. Grant Morrison just happens to be the form taken by this being when he made his appearence in Animal Man.
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All "My standards of evidence" are actually built on traditional standards of evidence. Asking for noncontradictory yet feesible evidence that actually CONNECTS to the text isn't much. It's also not like I'm the only user in existence that disagrees with your stats for the Writer. There are several others and the logic used is quite similar.

"The Writer" that is responsible for all of DC isn't an actual thing referenced in DC stories. The Writer shown and referenced is Grant Morrison and no one else which he even says.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer If "traditional standards of evidence" means doing everything you possibly can to twist information to fit your own narrative, then sure. Ok, and there are plenty who agree with me. There isn't safety for you in numbers.

Uh, it is an actual thing. Look at the interview where it's clearly stated that the overvoid was written on against its will. The Writer just showed up in limbo, big deal. All of the supposed contradictions you've brought up are because the writer literally wrote them to happen. Him getting attacked by that werewolf? He wrote on his typewriter for it to happen first. Him being written by others? He wrote himself into a story that HE created, in which he was controlled.
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All I do not do everything I can to possibly twist evidence lmao. Your accusations are becoming more baseless and more desperate everyday. I don't need safety in numbers when the people I do have supporting me at least have enough evidence to argue for themselves. Most of the people on this site that support the Writer wank support merely what you say but don't elaborate on that further and that's completely fine by "my standards" even though that would definitely be frowned upon in some places. People like Tahsin and Empty though have their own arguments and can argue against what you say with their own skill and proficiency instead of following me without actually understanding what they're supporting. It's not quantity but rather quality.

The metaconcept of a writer is a thing. It's not a thing in actual stories or at least it's not connected. The Writer that showed up in Animal Man which the profile is based on is bound and limited by his own text and his own stories. He wrote himself in but then proceeded to get controlled by his own story and he was killed because of Writer's Block. That is not willing himself to die. That's literally becoming prey to your own creation. He's not all writers. He's Grant Morrison. ONE writer which he says directly. You like comparing him to the One Above All every chance you get, don't you? Well, let me make an analogy. He's not like the One Above All in the slightest. He's like... an aspect (Above All Others) of an aspect (The Mystery) of an aspect (TOAA / AAO in HoI) of the One Above All. I've seen that interview a million times and it doesn't directly state him to be all Writers which is SHOWN in Animal Man where he says he doesn't write all characters. He's not all DC writers. He's one and that one aspect or whatever doesn't have any feats beyond that of Limbo. There's nothing to upgrade at that point.
Chijb
Chijb 1 mo 20 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
4 months member
The Writer Bruh writer v Stan lee is a better match up.
R165
R165 1 mo 30 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
5 months member
The Writer If TOAA were in DC, he would only be one aspect of The Presence
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 2 mo 1 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All TOAA slaps. Literally the Beyonder is enough to beat him considering he's only Limbo tier.
show 6 replies
Deathstroke_01
Deathstroke_01 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
19 months member
The Writer How is he limbo tier?
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All Because from what we've seen, that's where he's capped at. He didn't affect anything further.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer He's the one who writes the stories on the overvoid, GM himself stated this in an interview. A writer is not limited by the stories they create.
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All And yet he's bound by his own stories.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer No he isn't. It's just how he chooses to act. He's only "bound" by them if he wants to write them that way, but even then he isn't actually bound to them.
AkhilPDX
AkhilPDX 1 mo 27 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
53 months member
The One-Above-All Nothing you just said is supported by any of the comics.
Mr_Incognito
Mr_Incognito 9 mo 11 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
20 months member
The Writer The Writer takes the form of GM but is the combination of all DC writers who wrote the first story on the overvoid, above fiction. TOAA is a fictional character made to represent the writer of the story.
Actual writers > Fictional writer created to write the stories
Writer is tier 0, TOAA is high 1-A. Writer wins.
show 1 reply
Chijb
Chijb 1 mo 29 d
The One-Above-All vs The Writer
4 months member
The Writer Wrong

Voting feed

War_guy19
The One-Above-All wins!
CosmicKingThor
The One-Above-All wins!
SupremeDreams
The One-Above-All wins!
Chijb
The Writer wins!
hb
The Writer wins!
Deathstroke_01
The Writer wins!
R165
The Writer wins!
TashPuddle
The Writer wins!
voidstone
The One-Above-All wins!
Pedrof
The Writer wins!
An
The Writer wins!
Sh
The Writer wins!
Vendetta
The Writer wins!
NocticX
The Writer wins!
Dilorenzom
The One-Above-All wins!
SSpiderGwen
The Writer wins!
fo
The One-Above-All wins!
Omegadestroyer99
The Writer wins!
noc
The One-Above-All wins!
TH0R
The One-Above-All wins!
Atemporal
The One-Above-All wins!
Ka
The Writer wins!
Dhruv
The One-Above-All wins!
ubslucky
The Writer wins!
br
The One-Above-All wins!
MoNsTeR
The One-Above-All wins!
EmptyHand
The One-Above-All wins!
dog
The One-Above-All wins!
Michealdem17
The One-Above-All wins!
Dusk_Pikachu
The Writer wins!
Gu
The One-Above-All wins!
Alien_X
The One-Above-All wins!
Mr_Incognito
The Writer wins!
HolyJoe
The One-Above-All wins!
DevyEZ
The One-Above-All wins!
Ma
The One-Above-All wins!
Az
The Writer wins!
_W0lf_
The Writer wins!
Lovecraft
The Writer wins!
AkhilPDX
The One-Above-All wins!
Shadowatti
The Writer wins!