Searching...
Browse AD FREE for less than 84¢ a month with an SHDb membership.
Sn
46

SneachtaMacTire

Latest Comments

These are the 50 latest comments made by SneachtaMacTire

Sn
50 months member
46
Obi-Wan Kenobi (SWL) Sorry, ben is on the downswing, in the novelizations, he clearly states his body hurts from all the war wounds.

He would still put one hell of a fight, even Vader thought if he made a single mistake Ben would cut him down.
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Kylo Ren I mean, Revan alone can solo the lower half.
Cadeus can keep GM Luke occupied a long time
Sidious ties with Yoda
The Son can beat the Daughter.

which leaves:
Bane, Malak, Sion, Nihilus, Malgus, Krayt, Nox, Traya, Vader, Dark Empire Palpatine, Starkiller and Kylo Ren.

vs

Mace, , Kenobi, canon Anakin, Legends Anakin and Plo Koon.

Right off the bat Nihlus and Sion can't die, Nihlus requires a wound in the force to be killed, Sion only dies if he wishes to. none of the force users in the other team have what it takes to kill them, so they can keep Mace and Legends Anakin busy while Bane, Malak Malgus, Krayt, Nox, Traya, Vader, Dark Empire Palpatine, Starkiller and Kylo Ren gang up on Kenobi, Anakin and Koon, who Dark Empire Palpy can solo, once that's done and those three are dead, Mace and Legends Anakin would die in short order, and by this point so would everyone on the bottom right team, then Yoda, then the daughter then finally it will be GM Luke against the entirety of the left team.
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Obi-Wan Kenobi Revan solos, this is Empire Strikes back Luke... Grandmaster Luke would win, sure, not Empire strikes back.
Sn
50 months member
46
Revan (SWL) & Bastila Shan (SWL) ahahahahahahahahah

*breathes in*

hahahahahahahahahahah

I'm dying... Revan wouldn't even need to try... solo stomps.

Might as well pit Anakin vs younglings.
Sn
50 months member
46
Revan (SWL) Pretty sure the beginning of this fight would play out ALOT like the Revenge of the Sith fight between Jedi council and Palpy...

Question is... can Mace defeat Revan like he did Palpy?
hmmm...
I think not... Revan takes from both sides so Vaapaad wouldn't be nearly as effective...

So I'm giving this one with a MARGINAL advantage of 6/10
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Darth Vader Revan I'd put him on par with Anakin in ROTS, they are both tier 9 duelists but Revan is far more experienced and consistent with force powers than Anakin, so I'd give him the marginal win.

Nihlus I'd put him on par with with Empire Strikes back Luke, again advantage because of being more experienced with force powers plus I don't see what that Luke can do against Nihlus force drain, gradnmaster Luke, no issue, but not empire Luke..

Palpatine, Plagueis, Dooku, Grievous can all solo the rest.

Vader too except Padme... because... you know... it's Padme.
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Darth Vader This is actually a good fight, can't decide...

Meetra has defeated Nihlus
Revan and Caedus are on equal terms with Revan being more experienced and Caedus being the most powerful, Revan would take the win though.
Kyp CAN beat Vader, his force powers are way too OP for Vader to deal with them.
Plo has beaten Yoda in lightsaber combat, He can't beat Mace but he can definetly beat Marka Ragnos.

Shimrra and Marr would definetly lose, the question is who lasts longer... Ragnos or Shimrra and Marr...

I would give a victory with a 6/10 advantage to Team Nihlus.

I would say Ragnos would fall to Plo before Shimrra and Marr fell to Starkiller and Windu, I think they could hang in there a good amount of time, until Plo Koon comes to their help, maybe Marr falls to Mace but at that point it will be Shimrra and Plo vs Mace, who could hang in there until Meetra Surik comes to the aid.

Once Surik, Koon and Shimrra deal with Mace, they'd split for the other 3 and they'd fall in short order.
Last edited: 3 mo 29 d ago.
Sn
50 months member
46
Revan (SWL) I agree with the premise and end result, but I disagree that Caedus is a better lightsaber duelist than Revan only because he fought GM Luke, first Luke was only trying to incapacitate, which he did, while Jacen was trying to kill Luke 2nd Luke was wounded from his fight with Lumayia 3rd Revan fought some of the most powerful lightsaber duelists of his own era, there is no way to tell if he couldn't have achieved the same result as Jacen, so to me, and I mean this respectfully, its a non-sequitor 4th like Caedus Revan was an expert at using his environment to combat his foes, which is exactly how Luke almost got ganked by Jacen, so most likely Revan could have achieved the same.

I'd put them tied in lightsaber combat, both were highly capable skilled duelists on par with the best of the best.
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Revan (SWL) This is the most unfair fight I've seen, in here, this is Anakin vs the younglings all over again.
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Yoda Mace Kills Anakin
Yoda Kills Luke
Plo-Koon or Obi Wan or Shaak-Ti solos the rest
Sn
50 months member
46
Neutral They already fought, they tied. Yoda had to leave because the guard arrived.
Sn
50 months member
46
Neutral They tied, Yoda left because the guards arrived.
Sn
50 months member
46
Team Luke Skywalker I mean... Luke solos Kylo
Anakin solos Dooku
Mace solos Palpy
Obi Solos Grievous
Yoda Solos Vader
Ahsoka solos Ventress
Which leaves Rey and Qui-Gon vs Maul

The question is can Rey sub in for Obi-Wan in the phantom Menace?... ... I think so, she'd get stomped in lightsaber combat but if she uses the force she'd stomp... hmmm... anyway, if this is neutral ground there is no reason to think Qui-Gon would be left alone with Maul like in TPM, so I'd give them the fight, if not well they'd last long enough until Anakin finished Dooku or Luke finished Kylo and come to help, Qui-Gon lasted a solid 20 minutes in TPM, doubt Kylo would last as long against Luke and Anakin vs Dooku lasted 2 minutes.

So Team skywalker has got this in the bag.
Sn
50 months member
46
Rey & Grand Master Skywalker (SWL) ...

Here is how it goes:

*Rey Dies*

Epic fight starts, Obi-Wan and Anakin are better swordsmen but Luke is far better at force powers and wins but is rather battered and injured.

Seriously? who put Rey in this? like putting a hobbit in the middle of a dwarf fight...
Sn
50 months member
46
Grand Master Skywalker (SWL) Okay, this is an unfair fight, for supes, Luke is exactly the kind of opponent that is geared towards defeating him.
Sn
50 months member
46
Grand Master Skywalker (SWL) Who created this? who voted Rey wins? so many people smoking crack
Sn
50 months member
46
Luke Skywalker I mean, if we count movies only, then Anakin curb stomps Luke, Luke is basically on the level of Attack of the Clones Obi-Wan in ROTJ, capable, masterful, but not quite up there with ROTS Anakin.

But I'm assuming we're counting Expanded Universe, which is why Luke's stats are so high, Grandmaster Luke makes Palpatine look like a youngling in comparison, I mean his force blasts hurt Abeloth who is a cosmic being capable of casually consuming entire planets, maybe even solar systems as Luke himself stated she could and I quote "literally reshape the galaxy in any manner she wished"

So, I dunno, seems to me like Luke, if we count Legends, does have a massive advantage here.