PIS fights in movies

Created by DeanDinosaur6, 7 mo 16 d ago.

There was a topic for comics, so now movies.

Comments

BlotskyA
BlotskyA 5 mo 18 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
MarDC verison of the Justice League LOSING to the MarDC Verison of Scarecrow
show 2 replies
HeroicSacrifice123
PIS fights in movies
First you need to make that into a movie.
BlotskyA
BlotskyA 5 mo 18 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
which is 10 years
Dark_Wing
Dark_Wing 6 mo 19 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
Every Star Wars movie has at least one PIS moment.

TFM: Darth Maul being unable to stop Obi Wan from cutting him in half despite literally looking at him while he was jumping.
AotC: Padme falling in love with Hayden Christensen and Padme surviving the Battle on Geonosis.
RotS: Mace Windu being unable to sense Anakin's betrayal and being cheap shotted, Dooku defeating Obi Wan so easily (I've heard Palpatine help him but I'm not sure if there is any proof of that so I'll count it), Padme dying just from being sad, and Anakin being unable to use the Force to either Force Repulse his robes off so he didn't burn or levitate himself away from the lava.
Rogue One: Darth vader being unable to Force Pull the Death Star plans and being unable to stop the Rebles ship from escaping.
ANH: Princess Leia being able to resist Darth Vader's mind probe, Luke being able to out fly Darth Vader, and killing trained Stormtroopers despite not having any prior weapons experience.
ESB: Darth Vader being unable to use the Force to stop the Falcon from escaping Hoth
RotJ: the 501st being defeated by Ewoks, Luke somehow now being a Jedi Knight despite not having completed his training, the Rebels not being instantly obliterated by the Imperial Fleet, and worst of all Luke being equal to Vader.
TFA: Phasma lowering the shields, and Rey doing the Jedi Mind Trick. That's the only thing Rey did that I didn't agree with nor understand.
TLJ: the First Order being unable to hyperspace jump right closer to the Resistance ships, Rey being able to just copy Kylo Ren's skills like she's now Emerl or something like that, Finn defeating Phasma so easily, and Rey surviving a battle with several guards all of whom were trained by Snoke to fight a full power Luke Skywalker as stated in the Visual Guide for TLJ,
TROS: Palpatine losing so easily.
show 6 replies
Tyrannus
Tyrannus 6 mo 19 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
2. Padme surviving was plausible because there were jedi around. She proves she can handle herself too.
3. We can allow Mace for not sensing Anakin's betrayal because he was in the heat of the moment. Also I think it's the novel that says Anakin didn't intent to kill Mace just disarm him. He didn't know Sidious would kill him which is why he say "what have I done". It was too late now. Dooku was excellent so that's also plausible he beat Obi-Wan. Also Anakin had been dismembered of all non-mechanical limbs and in immense shock and pain.
4. I believe Vader wanted them to escape which is why the storm troopers put up a weak fight.
6. Were the 501st still alive? If they were their old age must have played a reasoning for their poor fight.
Dark_Wing
Dark_Wing 6 mo 19 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
2: there were droids shooting directly at her and since she didn't have anyway to block lazer fire, it's hard to believe she survived. Oh, and trained Jedi Masters were dying left and right during that battle but not Padme.
3: ok, though it is kind of stupid that Mace Windu of all people would be cheap shotted like that.
3.1: I'm well aware of that but if Anakin can beat Dooku and Obi Wan can match the power of a Dark Side empowered Anakin then why was Obi Wan just ragdolled? Heck Kenobi was shown to be a superior duelist twice in RotS 1st: when Dooku was crazy terrified of Kenobi's skills which was stated in the novel 2nd: when the Order sent Obi Wan to deal with General Grievous. There is no excuse for Kenobi losing so easily.
3.2: by that logic Darth Vader after his burns would be unable to use the Force. Also by that logic why could Darth Malgus continue to fight after being mortally wounded? Why could Darth Maul escape Nabu after being literally cut in half seconds prior? Why could Darth Bane wear the Orbulus Armor and still use the Force while wearing it? Why could freaking Kylo Ren get up after being shot by Chewie?
4: Wasn't that just a fan theory?
6: I thought they were, I could be wrong though. Even if it wasn't the 501st it was still a group of above average troopers who still lost to teddy bears.
Last edited: 6 mo 19 d ago.
Tyrannus
Tyrannus 6 mo 19 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
2. Anakin must have had her back.
3. They say even Lucas felt bad about having Mace killed off as he was part of the big 4. If only he had a cameo in TROS.
3.1 I believe it's implied Sidious helped out because he wanted it to be about Dooku vs Anakin. Something I can't explain however is why didn't Obi-Wan or Anakin maybe sense a dark side intervention in the fight?
3.2 For some reason the older sith seemed a lot stronger although I'm more inclined to believe what happened to Vader as more realistic. Maul didn't exactly make an escape plan and leave, things just happened. Getting shot is small compared to being dismembered of all your limbs and burning alive.
4. Tarkin asks Vader (or Vader asks Tarkin) if it was a good idea to let the rebels escape. Leia deduces this too and tells Han their escape was too easy.
6. I believe Lucas wanted to compare this to the Vietnam War. I think Tharwne had an explanation for their failure on Endor but I can't remember.
Dark_Wing
Dark_Wing 6 mo 18 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
2: there were moments in the battle where Padme was separated from Anakin.
3: okay, how would he being a camo fix how he died?
3.1: where is it implied? They didn't sense it because either A: it didn't happen or B: they were too focused on Dooku.
3.2: I'm well aware Maul didn't make an escape plan but he did escape in the comic in which he used the Force to do so. Oh, and Galen Marek took a lightsaber through the chest (right through his heart)m a really long fall, still got back up, bodied Vader, and battled Palpatine to a near stalemate; if you chose the Dark Ending Galen takes an entire ship to the back and not only survives but becomes a more powerful version of himself. If Malgus, Maul, Bane, and Marek can do it why can't full power enraged Anakin?
4: okay
6: still doesn't justify elite soldiers losing to teddy bears.
Tyrannus
Tyrannus 6 mo 18 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
3. I just wanted to see him again. Is that so bad?
3.1. Palpatine kind of makes gesture with his face. Immediately afterwards Dooku lifts him up and throws him away.
3.2. I never understood how you can get stabbed in the chest by Vader and still survive. That never made sense. Like I said the old sith tend to be stronger.
Dark_Wing
Dark_Wing 5 mo 26 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
@Tyrannus sorry for the late reply, I didn't see it.

3.1: no it isn't.
3.2: okay. Tho I don't remember any of the RotS tie ins even implying that
3.3: you can use the Force to will yourself to survive, it's how Anakin survived burning, how Kylo survived being shot, and how Maul survived being cut in half. The Old Republic Sith aren't too much more powerful than Vader and Marek so there's my point and that's why I don't understand him not being able to force pull himself out of the lava or force repulse his robes off.
Tyrannus
Tyrannus 7 mo 14 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
Everything Rey does in TFA and TLJ
show 2 replies
Jongensoden
Jongensoden 7 mo 14 d
PIS fights in movies
2 year member
Cough Everything kylo does cough
Dark_Wing
Dark_Wing 6 mo 19 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
@Tyrannus: the only thing that didn't make sense to me was how she did the Jedi Mind Trick but other than that, she's ok.
Jakcj
Jakcj 7 mo 14 d
PIS fights in movies
2 year member
Watch Batman and Robin. It's all PIS
show 1 reply
BlotskyA
BlotskyA 5 mo 18 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
being Honest, I Actually Like Batman & Robin
EmptyHand
EmptyHand 7 mo 15 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
Dark infinity soloing fict-- oh wait! That never happened!
Dark_Wing
Dark_Wing 7 mo 16 d
PIS fights in movies
1 year member
Basically every time the underdog wins