Zatanna vs Scarlet Witch

Who would win a fight?

Created by: Galactus

Character 1

Character 2

35 wins (50.7%)

Zatanna

Zatanna Zatara

10

Powergrid

Intelligence
95
95%
Strength
10
10%
Speed
25
25%
Durability
30
30%
Power
100
100%
Combat
60
60%

uSTATS

13
Intelligence
90
90%
Strength
55
55%
Speed
65
65%
Durability
65
65%
Power
100
100%
Combat
80
80%
Based on 38 entries.

Strength level

100 kg (220 lb)

Appearence

Gender female
Race Human
Height 5'7 // 170 cm
Weight 127 lb // 57 kg
34 wins (49.3%)

Scarlet Witch

Wanda Maximoff

20

Powergrid

Intelligence
100
100%
Strength
10
10%
Speed
30
30%
70%
Durability
70
70%
Power
100
100%
Combat
80
80%

uSTATS

18
Intelligence
85
85%
Strength
55
55%
Speed
60
60%
40%
Durability
70
70%
Power
95
95%
Combat
75
75%
Based on 69 entries.

Strength level

100 kg (220 lb)

Appearence

Gender female
Race Mutant
Height 5'7 // 170 cm
Weight 132 lb // 59 kg

Comments

Voted: Scarlet Witch

No more Zatanna takes 3 seconds. Hctiw telracs eid takes 5 seconds. I'm so glad I can say this; Wanda speedblitz.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Or Zatanna just says "Eid." Which takes one second.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

Or Wanda just snaps her fingers and Zatanna disappears.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

That would take more than a second. And Wanda can't erase anyone stronger than her. Zatanna far exceeds her in power.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

She does not even come close to Wanda's powers. This is a matter of trickery, Wanda is obviously more powerful. It's irrelevant if Zatanna was named as more powerful than Doctor Fate, cause feats > statements.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

She is not only stated to be the strongest member of JL Dark, she is also portrayed as it. She's also been portrayed as the strongest member of the main Justice League, which would again put her above Doctor Fate, as well as Hal Jordan and Captain Atom. Zatanna is far above Wanda. And even if she wasn't, Zatanna could warp her away faster than Wanda could do it to her.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

So? Wanda is above all of the Justice League members at her peak. So, it's irrelevant.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

This isn't her peak though. This is normal Scarlet Witch, not HoM Scarlet Witch. And Zatanna is stronger than HoM Scarlet Witch anyway.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

No, she most definently is not. What gave you the idea that she is?!
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

With the Chaos Wave, HoM Wanda is high multiversal. Zatanna is multiversal+. Multiversal+ > high multiversal.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

Zatanna isn't multiversal+. And just because she is "said to be" more powerful than someone, doesn't mean she truly is.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Yet that's the logic you use to say LF Scarlet Witch is above Beyonder. And unlike her, Zatanna is actually portrayed as being stronger than Swamp Thing, Doctor Fate, etc.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

Can you give me the scan? And can you send it on Discord?
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

I don't have the scan where she's stated as the strongest, but I do have scans where she casually stomps a nightmare imp and makes him her bitch. I can find absolutely no information about them online, but I imagine they're comparable to 5d imps.
https://m.imgur.com/lJRCRd7
https://m.imgur.com/hd8vdey
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Unholy godstomp. Zatanna > Swamp Thing >> Doctor Fate >>>> Scarlet Witch
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Swamp Thing is not powerful, but is so hard to be killed.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Swamp Thing is a higher dimensional entity comparable to Mr. Mxyzptlk. He is very powerful.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

lol i didn't know that 😁
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

lol i didn't know that 😁
1+ years member.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

scarlet witch is a better fighter
5+ years member.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

It looks like another toss-up to me folks....
Voted: Zatanna

Zatanna for the win. The magic in the DC universe is more powerful than in the Marvel universe. This was brought up in the Avenger/Justice League crossover. Zatanna's control is far more reliable. And for those that say Scarlet Witch can warp reality. Magic in itself is the ultimate manipulation of reality.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Wanda is to unstable to win consistently s gets it 6 of 10
2+ years member.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

The Scarlet Witch has way more abilities she can choose from and is extremely Intelligent which means she can use her magic more effeciently.
3+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

...by voting for Zatanna
3+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

somebody break the tie
Voted: Scarlet Witch

There is no tie now.
2+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

This is a hard, hard, fight. Zatanna is more experienced and has better magical attacks, but Scarlet Witch has the ability to warp reality. I think that Scarlet Witch has the upper hand with the reality warp, but I believe that Zatanna is smart and powerful enough to find a counter for it with her wide range of magic. I think after a long exhausting match, Zatanna wins.
1+ years member.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

Who needs training when you have intelligence brain vs strength brain always win
Voted: Scarlet Witch

That is so true.
1+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

What does that intelligence matter without training to channel it through?
Voted: Scarlet Witch

I agree with @LordTracer that experience is more important than intelligence but I still thinks Wanda wins
Voted: Scarlet Witch

@LordTracer Wanda was trained by Agatha Harkness and is incredibly skilled in using her powers. She is trained in h2h combat as well. She wins.
2+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

Scarlet Witch and Zatanna are two vary powerful characters, although Wanda lacks the experience and training, that Zatanna has.
Voted: Scarlet Witch

To quote Dcfan123, "Who needs training when you have intelligence."
3+ years member.
Voted: Zatanna

You can know about every single type of gun in the world, but unless you actually practice and train with them, your knowledge is basically useless