Superman and Martian Manhunter
-vs-
Silver Surfer and Thor

Created by: God_of_Thunder
7 wins (35%)
SupermanMartian Manhunter

Superman and Martian Manhunter

90

Creator: God_of_Thunder

Members

Superman (Kal-El)
Martian Manhunter (J'onn J'onzz)

13 wins (65%)
Silver SurferThor

Silver Surfer and Thor

133

Creator: Amirvel

Members

Silver Surfer (Norrin Radd)
Thor (Thor Odinson)

Comments

windshadow
346 days ago
windshadow
Team Battle
1+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

VERY close battle.
ManofPower
346 days ago
ManofPower
Team Battle
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

This battle is s awesome but I'm going with Silver Surfer Nd Thor
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@Spectre94: I am enjoying it a bit. Is this story arc what the Justice League movie is going to be based on?
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@remy94: Silver Surfer can absorb infinite amounts of energy so absorbing the sun wont be a problem. Also, Superman cant have the whole sun inside him. If he did, the whole solar system would die. So, Silver Surfer would be absorbing a little amount of the sun, which he would do instantaneously
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@SirSpidey perhaps I made a mistake, I'll look into it and get back to you. How are you enjoying the comic series?
remy94
1 year ago.
remy94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Superman and Martian Manhunter

@SirSpidey I'm not arguing that Superman's energy can't be drained same as any of these characters but if he was supercharged I'm pretty sure Silver Surfer would have to absorb the entire sun to stop him.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@remy94: If it can enter into Superman, it has to come out. I mean he isnt inpervious or anything. Why do thing Superman has to recharge his energy? Because he EXERTS it while doing too much
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@Spectre94: I read The New 52 Justice League (2011) Issues 1,2,3, and 4. No where does Superman and Aquaman exchange blows. Are these the wrong comics or something?
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Yes they are at a powerlevel that is truely insane !
They are the realy heavy characters of Marvel and Dc comics.
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Thanks @God_of_Thunder of course I voted for Thor & Silver Surfer as the realistic winner. But I just wanted it to be noted that all these characters are extremely powerful and none of them are unstoppable.
Dellmamy45
1 year ago.
Dellmamy45
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

This is a Litt as Fight
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Yes i agree Spectre that characters as powerful as The man of steel and the Mighty Asgardian warrior God got Durability to survive close to anything they are created this way. Thats something i have also explained before in this forum.
A sun dipped Superman and Martian Manhunter versus a warriors madness Thor and the Silver Surfer is a battle that could destroy eben a galaxie !
Mental attacks is of no use in this battle. If Superman and Martian Manhunter may trick the insane Thor in attacking Silver Surfer than they could be victorious.
If not Mighty Thor and the Silver Surfer would be victorious !
For truth the four of them could probably join forces instead.
What a team they would be their power is redicules !
remy94
1 year ago.
remy94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Superman and Martian Manhunter

Well this may be true @SirSpidey, but I'd have to agree with @Spectre94 he isn't a accidental meta human as the Hulk or Flash, once solar energy is stored in his body that's where it stays. And Silver Surfer won't even be considering it when his mind is being attacked.
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@SirSpidey I fallow all media as long as it's based on canon comics, in the comic I am referring to Aquaman dose exchange blows with Superman, but Ocean Master is the one how used Aquaman's Trident against man of steel.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@remy94: Superman could be in the sun for centuries and it still wont matter because he would get his energy absorbed instantly
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@sandman325: Wonder Woman got her tiara from an alien from the planet Alpha Negra who retrieved it in a fight against the Phenegs
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

@Spectre94: Are you sure you have read the comic? Because I read issues 1-4 and not once did I see Superman or Aquaman even touch each other. And Im not going to watch something that is not canon to the comics. Why would you even think of suggesting something like that? This makes me wonder if your just making this up
remy94
1 year ago.
remy94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Superman and Martian Manhunter

In my opinion the man of steel sun dipped is unstoppable, and Martain Manhunter will attack both of them mentally and physically.
sandman325
1 year ago.
sandman325
Team Battle
1+ years member.
Not voted yet

Also, Parasite is in the Superman rogues gallery and all he does is absorb energy.
sandman325
1 year ago.
sandman325
Team Battle
1+ years member.
Not voted yet

Not picking a side but Wonder Woman's tiara is magic in nature.
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

The new 52 Justice League #1 #2 #3 #4, or you could just watch the film Justice League Throwe of Atlantis.
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Of course you haven't read the comic because you are a Marvel Fanboy @SirSpidey.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

I have never read a comic where Superman has been stabbed in the heart with Aquamans Trident (if he has, please give me the comic), has never been reduced down to a skeleton by kryptonite (if he has, please give me the comic). And Wonder Womans tiara is not magic. Also, just because it hasent happened yet, doesnt mean you can make up a reason why it hasent happened. Also, what does being a meta human have to do with anything?
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Since there is no cases. Superman's energy can't be absorbed once it is stored in his body. He's not a meta-human as the Hulk.
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

I'm not arguing that magic doesn't harm the man of steel, I'm just stating magic has never been enough to stop him, if he can be stabbed in the heart, with Aquaman's Trident, hit by hawkman's gauntlet, have his throat cut open by Wonder Woman, or being reduced to nothing but a skeleton by kryptonite, in all these cases Superman healed instantly, there is no reason why Clark couldn't survive anything short of the godblast.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

No, characters have never been SHOWN to absorb Supermans energy. That doesnt mean they arent able to do so, it just means that DC writing is awful. Also, I said Solomon Grundy doesnt UTILIZE magic. There you go again putting words into peoples mouths. Theres a big difference between being made from magic and actually being able to use the magic you were made with. Also, about your last statement, thats like saying a human can survive anything short of a a stab wound. Of course a human will be able to survive a punch but its still going to hurt him
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

You can't be saying Silver Surfer can absorb Superman's solar energy if no other character has been able to do this in the Dc universe, your making false accusations. Plus if you didn't know Solomon Grundy was magic in nature, then you must not know to much about these characters. I'll also state what I've stated before Superman would survive anything short of the godblast.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

You mean just to name all of them. Out of all of the villains you mentioned, except for Solomon Grundy (which I dont know why you think he utilizes magic), they have proven to beat Superman all the time when they fight because they use magic. I mean seriously though, Gog literally was killing every single Superman, one by one, in every alternate Earth. And just because DC writing is so one sided and awful and dont look at all the possibilities, doesnt mean that Silver Surfer cant take away Supermans sun radiation (light energy is sun radiation). You cant just take away a characters power simply because it has never been done to another character
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Mister Mxyzptlk, Black Adam, Eclipso, Solomon Grundy, Gog just to name a few. And since Superman has faced opponents with the same abilities as Silver Surfer and has never had his light energy (not radiation) absorbed, there is no reason Norrin can do it.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Thats not what the comics dictate. Plus, what villain that Superman fights soley uses magic? None. Because DC doesnt want him to lose
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Well then Kryptonite and magic isn't a weakness for the man of steel since he always finds a way around it.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

In my opinion, a weakness is a weakness, there isnt a way around it
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Basically any superhero with sufficient durability could survive the maximum force of Mjolnir in my opinion, characters at Thor's & Superman's level are not meant to be stopped, they may survive just about anything even their weaknesses.
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Silver Surfer could just absorb all of Supermans solar radiation as seen in the comics when he faced the Hulk
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Yes there you are on to something spectre !
In this mode the Asgardian cross breed is not a team player and may even attack his best friend. The ability to enter warriors madness  should only been used in the most dire situations when the God lacks company.
If this happens the battle may end up with the warrior God pounding all inclueding allies with Mjolnir. Is there any superhero exclueding Spectre that may prevail a maximum magical  charged blow from Mjolnir when in warriors madness ? The battle may end up with all dead and Thor as a vegetable !
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Unless of course Superman tricks the insane Thor into fighting Silver Surfer, or Martain Manhunter takes over his mind in his weakened state, these of course are just different ways the battle could play out. I personally think Thor will lose against a sun dipped Superman, but that's my opinion.
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Yes that might become an intresting battle, the God now realy realy powerful but also insane !
Superman with no weakness against Mighty Thors Asgardian magic and fuled by the sun for maximum boost will push the God to maximum for victory. Its not a very good strategy getting close to a warrior god in that state ! How ever it may be possible to outsmart him he will then also have to meat Silver Surfer.
I think in the end the outcome will give the same winners.
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Actually I meant while Thor is in his worries madness state, not after. when in this state Thors power increases but it also makes him insane, and characters can defeat him this way as Hulk has proven.
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

You mean after Mighty Thor have been calmed down after a warriors madness state ?
Superman also with no weakness to a Mjolnir blazing of magical energy ?
Then i think the warrior god will be in trouble because he is burned out after his berserker fury and his magic will not give him an advantage.
This will become a very intresting battle !
Spectre94
1 year ago.
Spectre94
Team Battle
2+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Let's just say Superman is Sun dipped and no longer has a vulnerability to magic, and Thor is in his wakened worries madness state, this should make the battle even.
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Yes sirspidey
Silver Surfer and Sentry
Versus
Superman and Martian Manhunter
Would be a much more even battle, a very intresting one actuelly !
SirSpidey
1 year ago.
SirSpidey
Team Battle
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Not even a fight. This is too easy for Thor. Replace Thor with Sentry then its a fair fight
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer and Thor

Bouth Mighty Thor and the Silver Surfer beats Superman and Martian Manhunter in a one vs one battle.
Probably the closest battle would be Silver Surfer vs Martian Manhunter this is because of the weaknesses of the of steel that may be exploited for victory.

Active users (last 2 minutes)

2005- 2019 - Superhero Database | SuperheroMovies.net