Silver Surfer vs Thor

Who would win a fight?

Created by: Vagabond

Character 1

Character 2

51 wins (47.7%)

Silver Surfer

Norrin Radd

47

Powergrid

Intelligence
80
80%
Strength
100
100%
Speed
100
100%
0%
Durability
90
90%
Power
100
100%
Combat
35
35%

uSTATS

46
Intelligence
80
80%
Strength
95
95%
Speed
100
100%
0%
Durability
100
100%
Power
100
100%
Combat
65
65%
Based on 97 entries.

Strength level

Incalculable / Limit unknown

Appearence

Gender male
Race Alien
Height 6'4 // 193 cm
Weight 225 lb // 101 kg
56 wins (52.3%)

Thor

Thor Odinson

30

Powergrid

Intelligence
85
85%
Strength
100
100%
Speed
85
85%
15%
Durability
100
100%
Power
100
100%
Combat
100
100%

uSTATS

25
Intelligence
70
70%
Strength
95
95%
Speed
85
85%
15%
Durability
95
95%
Power
95
95%
Combat
90
90%
Based on 208 entries.

Strength level

Incalculable / Limit unknown

Appearence

Gender male
Race Asgardian
Height 6'6 // 198 cm
Weight 640 lb // 288 kg

Comments

Voted: Silver Surfer

Funny how people use the argument of Thor beating Surfer multiple times to vote on this battle. Surfer was clearly holding back those times, and even Surfer has beated Thor few times.
-
Morals on - Thor
Morals off - Surfer stomps
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Lol, "beated." Learn English before you speak. Basically what you just said was, "I am just going to ignore the fact that Thor has beaten the Silver Surfer four different times due to my complete and utter bias against Thor and make up some bulls*** claim saying that the Silver Surfer holds back against Thor with zero evidence backing it up." Instead of living in denial, how about you accept what the comics dictate and move on. What comic book evidence do you have that suggests the Silver Surfer always holds back against Thor? In which comic has the Silver Surfer defeated Thor?
Voted: Silver Surfer

You're native english speaker and you speak worse than I do. Chill out. Anyway, how do you know I don't have evidence/proof? Unlike you, I prove anything I say or claim, on the other hand, you just assume things, like TWSAIS being on the level of Beyonders etc.
Anyway, a noob such as yourself probably doesn't know that Silver Surfer is never bloodlusted and never goes all-out, because if he does, he would be using the full potential of the Power Cosmic, which is above anything Thor has.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

So many claims and still has zero evidence to back them up. Pathetic as always. Last time I checked, I was not the one saying "beated" and "You are native speaker." So how could you possibly speak better than me? This is just another example of you making claims with zero evidence to back them up. How do I know that you don't have any evidence? Because unlike you, I have actually read every comic in which Thor and the Silver Surfer have fought and nowhere in those comics does it say or portray the Silver Surfer holding back. Kid, you prove s***. Whenever I ask for evidence from you, you realize that you actually don't have any evidence so you just reference a random comic book issue with no correlation to your claim whatsoever. Quite pathetic to say the least. It is a fact that Those Who Sit Above In Shadow are Beyonders, as I have proven time and time again using the comics. You are the one who refuses to accept the facts due to your bias against Thor and your hatred towards Thor for being the most powerful superhero. Yeah, I am a noob even though I have been on this site two years longer than you have. Makes sense. This is yet another example of you making claims with zero evidence to back them up. In which comic does it say or portray the Silver Surfer never becomes bloodlusted and never goes all out? The Silver Surfer admitted in Silver Surfer Volume 1 #4 that Thor's Magic is more powerful than his Power Cosmic. So yet again, this is another example of you making a claim with zero evidence to back it up
Voted: Silver Surfer

You are a native speaker, but you make more grammatical mistakes, so don't try to cover it up.
Oh, stop! STOP! PLEASE, I'M BEGGING YOU. Thor is not the most powerful superhero (he's lucky if he ends up in top 20) and I don't hate him, I hate Thor's fanboys, such as yourself.
Nice try, that Silver Surfer hasn't yet mastered Power Cosmic, he has become much stronger later on.
1+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer

Silver Surfer is extremely powerful and if he really wants to, he might be able to stomp Thor. Only reason Thor usually wins is that Surfer holds back against him (Surfer holds back more than Superman) and is a pacifist. I wouldn't say it is too bad of a stomp, but Surfer wins pretty well. I think he can take on both Hulk AND Thor and win. Only people more powerful than him are probably Doctor Strange, Scarlet Witch, and Zarathos.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

The Silver Surfer even admitted that Thor is more powerful than him. Not once has the Silver Surfer said that he holds back against Thor, but on the other hand, Thor is actually shown to hold back against the Silver Surfer. In fact, Thor was holding back against a Loki empowered Silver Surfer and still won. And why would the Silver Surfer hold back against a god who has beaten him four different times? The closest thing to the Silver Surfer beating Thor was a draw and it was only a draw due to outwardly interference. They have drawn three times and if there wasn't any interferences, based on the fact that Thor has beaten him everytime they have fought without interferences, it is safe to say that Thor would have won all three times
Voted: Thor

How is SS winning?!? Thor has beaten him every time they've fought.
Voted: Silver Surfer

If Surfer is bloodlusted, there is nothing Thor can do to him
Voted: Thor

Same goes to Thor.
Voted: Thor

Simple. One is a God and one is not. Thor wins
Voted: Silver Surfer

Silver Surfer vs Thor
Silver Surfer has been shown to take on galactus before so has Thor
But silver surfer is way WAY more powerful than thor
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Thor has beaten him every time they've fought
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Thor has beaten him every time they've fought
Voted: Silver Surfer

I've got my chance to do it again.
Voted: Silver Surfer

I have to break this tie.
Voted: Thor

I did it for you
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

50/50 Now xD
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Whoaaaa... This changed, and it shouldn't have, Thor can still beat Silver Surfer, he has pretty much all the time in the comics.
Voted: Silver Surfer

Silver Surfer is just too strong for Thor to win against him.
Voted: Silver Surfer

Thor is winning against Silver Surfer ??? This is bullshit. Totally bullshit.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

If you actually read comics, you would know that Thor beats Silver Surfer almost every time they fight
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Yes because the godblast (a blast that releases his godforce) was once used and mjolnir broke because of all the energy
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Ya his God Force is stated as to being even more powerful than Mjolnir itself. Plus, Thor can just go and get his battle axe
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

The power of Mighty Thor come from his herritage as a true God, a cross breed Asgardian and Elder God.
This is why he got his Godly energy the God force that may be released in the God blast. Also he still is a warrior God with vast expirience, but of course Mjolnir is a weapon beyond imagination loosing it would be devastating.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

I am of course keeping my vote on Thor, he will always be the main wielder of Mjolnir even if he currently isn't in possession of it. I just wanted to see your thoughts on the subject.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

In my opinion warriors madness only makes Thor more reckless, I also think The god of thunder is no where near the same level as Silver Surfer without Mjolnir.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Well since Silver Surfer has faced Thor in the past I'm sure he will learn from his mistakes.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

I think that the God only got one option to defeat Silver Surfer without Mjolnir and its to enter Warriors Madness.
Silver Surfer avoid coming in close range to the God using his insane speed keeping distance. Multiply Blasts that blow up planets keep hitting the God, blasts that may not be absorbed or deflected without his magical hammer.
If how ever Silver Surfer is not succesful in keeping distance he will be knocked out.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

So who do you think would be the victorious Thor without Mjolnir or a full powered Silver Surfer?
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Spiderman is the most popular superhero in the world but is not supposed to battle Heralds of Galactus or the likes as Juggernaut and the incredible Hulk. When the outcome is unrealistic and not the way its supposed to fans become confused and say Batman defeats Superman.
Mighty Thor with Mjolnir is close to unbeatable and defeats Silver Surfer as well as close to anybody ! An artifact of Mythological proportions, this warhammer is a Omega weapon that may absorb 20 percent of the universe. Of course this weapon enhance its wielders power !
Mighty Thor without Mjolnir is still a Warrior God of insane power but beatable as his Versatility drops and to some degree also his power output.
To separate the God from Mjolnir is close to impossible but if someone plans to defeat him this is what have to be done !
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

In the Marvel universe this is the two most powerful superheroes the top dogs.
There are some characters sometimes challenge them as the Sentry, incredible Hulk, Phoenix force Jean Grey or Doctor Strange but over time its pretty safe suggest they are the most powerful.
Comic book writers often let the outcome of battles support the plot of a story rather than have a realistic outcome. Characters favored of the writer or from fans become victorious when they should loose.
In my mind its better have things the way its supposed to be. A human born Mutate with incredible powers may not compare with a Super powerful Alien far beyond the human species in all ways possible. A true God not just someone gaining powers from the Gods who have been worshiped and is some thousends of years with vast expirience is of course also far beyond a Mutate.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Thor has proven to be formiddable even without his hammer. He created a blast, without his hammer, so powerful that he couldnt do the same with his hammer
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Seeing how Thor is no longer worthy of wielding Mjolnir this battle my have a different outcome.
1+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer

Silver Surfer's power is too great even for Thor....If Surfer wanted to beat Thor he could easily do it, as he has done against BRB.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Not even a fight, as proven in the comics
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Very close battle but Thor takes it like come on he is a god.
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

close one, stalemate.
1+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Thor has already beaten the Silver Surfer several times in the comics. The first time they fought in the classic Silver Surfer #4, Surfer even flat out states, "I have seen his mallet's magic! It is truly mightier than my cosmic force!" Then in the Blood and Thunder story arc, Thor knocks out the Silver Surfer even after Surfer says he's not going to hold back. When Surfer wakes up, he gets help from Adam Warlock, but then Thor beats Surfer and Warlock at the same time and they have to flee. The Silver Surfer is easily one of Marvel's most powerful heroes, but Thor is just a bad matchup for him. Thor can absorb Surfer's energy attacks with Mjolnir while Thor is just a much better melee fighter than Surfer.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

This is the two most powerful superheroes in the Marvel universe, bouth created of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.
The Silver Surfer is Stans personal favorit of all his creations and created in 66.
Mighty Thor created first in 62 with the purpose to be the most powerful superhero of all.
The subject may be read about in the Forum The most powerful superheroes in comics
3+ years member.
Voted: Silver Surfer

Silver Surfer would definitely take this battle, but what do you guys think about Silver Surfer vs Odin?
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

If The Silver Surfer was a warrior that could challenge the god of thunder, this battle would have a different outcome.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

This is a very important observation youre doing Remy the very essence of this Asgardian Elder god cross breed is a warrior. The very purpose of the character is to be this ultimate warrior god who battle monsters.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Perhaps the only reason for the Mighty Thor's victory over the Silver Surfer is because, Norrin Radd is no warrior, compared to the Son of Odin.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

They have fought before, a calm Thor would lose, but Thor usually becomes enraged and ends up beating the **** out of him. Imma say Thor 6-7/10 times.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

Thor is a absolute powerhouse, although he is not the most powerful superhero in comics! there are other characters who will easily overpower him, like, Silver Surfer, the Spectre, and even Superman. my winner is the Surfer.
2+ years member.
Voted: Thor

The Mighty warrior god of Norse myths versus The Silvery alien and demigod of the universe Silver surfer!
A true battle of titans the two most powerful superheroes in comics !
The magical powers of the gods and Mjolnir versus the power cosmic ends with victory for the god but its a very hard battle !

Active users (last 2 minutes)

2005- 2018 - Superhero Database | SuperheroMovies.net